Camping At Mogao Caves

Dunhuang_in_China Subei_in_Gansu Dunhuang_Area

When we had been at the Mogao Caves the day before, a light breeze whisked through the leaves of the trees planted beside the caves. The next day, though, as we were walking into the desert to find a campsite, the wind whipped across the desert hills. Storming out of the red mountains that face the Mogao Caves, sand blew across us to the point that we sometimes could not face forward. For a minute or two, we would simply turn our backs against the wind and wait it out, hoping that it would not be too long before we could see again.

Desert Panorama

Desert Panorama

This was the desert and there was an element of danger to it, so we did not go far. We pitched our tent only two miles from the Mogao Caves. If we climbed atop one of the wavy dirt mounds, we could see we were never out of sight of the tall Wu Zetian Buddha. It was still hot, and we were carrying heavy bags.

Debilitating Heat

Debilitating Heat

Despite how close we were to one of China’s biggest tourist attractions, this was wild country. The red mountains towered a thousand feet above us, and their little fingers reached out for us, shaped by centuries of flash floods. Inside the fingers, we could see evidence of surging waters over the millenniums, the boulders jammed into crevices by surging waters. Opposite the mountains, there were sand dunes even taller than the red mountains, looking as though they were waiting to blow over and swallow us.

Desert Sands Waiting to Swallow Us

Desert Sands Waiting to Swallow Us

We pitched our tent in the gully of one of the mountain edge’s fingers. Our site was far enough out of the way that I thought it would not be washed away if a flash flood happened.

Desert

Desert

In the distance, farther along the mountains edge, away from the Dunhuang caves, there were two pagodas standing tall. I walked half an hour through the late afternoon desert heat to examine them. There was a modern structure hiding behind the two pagodas. It was unclear what the structure was for and when the pagodas had been built. They could have been built one hundred years ago, or a thousand years ago. The desert’s dryness preserves things for centuries; the desert’s emptiness makes it more likely that it will be left alone.

Tent with the afternoon mountains

Tent with the afternoon mountains

Night fell, and the desert became cool. We ate raisins, enjoyed PBRs and watched stars drift across the desert sky. This place had once been a crossroad, a node along the Silk Road, a center of the Buddhist world. Perhaps it was the PBR, but I looked up at the sky and wondered what scholar’s footsteps we had walked in that afternoon, what Silk Road caravan had camped where we were camping.

Tent at Night

Tent at Night

We fell asleep in the silence of the desert.

Milky Way over the Desert

Milky Way over the Desert

Crescent Lake and the White Horse Pagoda

Dunhuang_in_ChinaSubei_in_Gansu

Dunhuang_Area

Crescent Lake - Looks fantastic, right?

Crescent Lake – Looks fantastic, right?

When we came up on the Crescent Lake, Galen’s disappointment was palpable. Hordes of Chinese tourists in bright orange sand boots milled about. Galen took a few pictures and then shrugged. He asked me to get a video of him being disappointed.

Orange Boots Everywhere

Orange Boots Everywhere

I was more prepared. I have walked into too many Chinese tourist traps. I did not allow my hopes to get up too much, so I could not be too disappointed.

We loved this guy on the right. He just looked so hilarious with his giant sideburns, his cowboy hat and his orange boots

We loved this guy on the right. He just looked so hilarious with his giant sideburns, his cowboy hat and his orange boots

Crescent Lake Park is one of the most well-known attractions in all of China. In Dunhuang, it is the second attraction only because the Mogao Caves are just so amazing and historically important. The lake is really more of a small pond that has been an oasis among the sandy desert for some time. The photos of this place are impressive, a slender mirror of water, flanked by wooden buildings that look like they are fourteen hundred years old, all of it enveloped by mountains of sand. Galen had been salivating at the thought of photography at this place since we won the grant from Outside Magazine.

It just looks old

It just looks old.

But the complex of buildings was only built to look old. In fact, the complex had been built in the 1990’s. Nothing important happened here. What makes this place special? The sand dunes were impressive, but the whole town was surrounded by sand. It seemed silly to pay to see this sand. The ticket for Crescent Lake was one hundred r.m.b., about seventeen dollars, almost as expensive as our hotel room.

Four Wheeler Rides

Four Wheeler Rides

Compounding this all was the fact that the Park had been completely sold out to tourism. If you had money, there were camel rides, glider rides, helicopter rides, cart rides and a four-wheeler ride. A sprinkler system had been installed, and men with water trucks were watering the sand. A park was supposed to be a place that preserves, but, in the miles and miles of dunes surrounding Dunhuang, this was the least natural spot.

Over Priced Camel Rides

Over Priced Camel Rides at Crescent Lake

Later, after the disappointment of Crescent Lake, I visited the White Horse Pagoda alone. The day was hot, the desert sun beating down on me. It was in the middle of nowhere, rural farmland. I had to walk a half a mile from where the bus stopped to get to the Pagoda. The compound surrounding the Pagoda was quiet. Women who sold tickets had few visitors, so they played mahjong in the shade as their children were horsing around at the entrance. The tourist trail, so evident elsewhere in Dunhuang, had skipped the White Horse Pagoda.

The White Horse Pagoda - Not Grand, but Real

The White Horse Pagoda – Not Grand, but Real

I did not even bother to buy a ticket. Instead, I went around the outside wall of the compound into a nearby farm, passing a sign that threatened a fine if I crossed into the field. I climbed up a several foot high pile of dirt and looked over the compound’s wall. I could see the entirety of the Pagoda as well, if not better, than I could inside.

Going around the Entrance

Going around the Entrance

The Pagoda was built by Kumarajiva in around 400 A.D. to honor his horse. Kumarajiva was one of the men who made the Silk Road. His father was a Kashmiri Prince, his mother was from Kuche, once a Buddhist kingdom along the Silk Road, now a truck stop in China. Kumarajiva was one of the most important men in transmitting Buddhism into China, translating the Diamond Sutra into Chinese. While Kumarajiva was traveling, his trusty steed died. He built the Pagoda to honor the horse. The Pagoda was only thirty something feet tall. There was nothing grand about it, but I liked it. I continued walking further into the farm. There were fields with small strips of green with yellow dirt earth. Beyond a few trees, there were the towering sand dunes off in the distance, though these were free to enter and not crawling with orange-booted tourists.

Mud Structures

Mud Structures

Further on, I realized that there were small mud structures surrounded by barbed wire fences sitting quietly in the middle of this field. I approached them. The structures were clearly old. No sign was there to explain them. The only way I could tell they were old and important was the barbed wire around them and the cracks running down the sides, showing centuries of weathering. This is what I love about China, when the history is real. This place is now nowhere, but, before, I realize, Kumarajiva must have built the Pagoda here because it was a center of activity. The structures must be more than a thousand years old.

Real History

Real History

But the tour groups are not interested in the Pagoda or these structures. No one is here. The White Horse Pagoda is not at all grand, but it is real. Unlike Crescent Lake, something really happened here. This is real history. This is ancient.

 

 

Don’t miss a single video from our adventure. Click the red Youtube button below to subscribe!

Cutest Animals on the Silk Road – Part II

As I mentioned in Part I of Cutest Animals along the Silk Road, Sunday is the slowest day for the blog, so, just to try to have a little fun, I’ve decided to just throw a post up with photos of cute animals that we have seen here along the Silk Road.

Lazy

Lazy

What you looking at?

What you looking at?

Morning Traffic Jam

Morning Traffic Jam

Screaming Salesman

Screaming Salesman

Can you do this with your Tongue?

Can you do this with your Tongue?

I'm Not Waiting on a Lady, I'm just waiting on a friend.

I’m Not Waiting on a Lady, I’m just waiting on a friend.

Village Dogs

Village Dogs

Out

Out

Trash Dog

Trash Dog

Big Dog

Big Dog

Restaurant Chicken

Restaurant Chicken

Not Happy

Not Happy

Tibetan Temple Kitty

Tibetan Temple Kitty

Dunhuang

Dunhuang_in_ChinaSubei_in_Gansu

Desert around Dunhuang

Desert around Dunhuang

Dunhuang is the Silk Road par excellence. From Xian to here, the route of the Silk Road is clear, running west-northwest. Other than the side trip we took to Xining, along a route that was sometimes used when the main Silk Road was too dangerous, there is really only one way to go along the land route of the Silk Road: it is the low-lying road that runs along the foot of the Qinlian Mountains.

Desert of Dunhuang

Desert of Dunhuang

In Dunhuang, the Qinlian Mountains peter out in the hot air of Taklamakan Desert, the world’s second largest sand desert. Here the Silk Road splits; it runs along the edge of the Taklamakan, either pressing against the Tianshan Mountains on the north end or the Kunlun Mountains and the Tibetan Plateau on the southern end.

Moving across the Desert

Moving across the Desert

The location of Dunhuang made it important in ancient times for lines of communications. As far back as Emperor Wudi, our friend whose grave had the Naked Terracotta Warriors, Dunhuang was an important border post.

Lonely Border Post

Lonely Border Post

This made Dunhuang a flourishing entrepôt, where cultures from all over Asia mixed and melted together. It was through Dunhuang that Buddhism moved from India, where the Buddha was born, to Afghanistan to China and on into Korea, and Vietnam.

The Largest of the Mogao Caves

The Largest of the Mogao Caves

This history has left its mark. Dunhuang is still home to relics of the Silk Road, particularly the Mogao Caves, a series of hundreds of Buddhist caves dug out of a cliff face and intricately painted on the inside.

Inside the Caves

Inside the Caves

Today, the caves are claimed by China as one of the wonders of Chinese civilization. In fact, they were constructed and painted by a variety of Buddhist, Han Chinese, Tibetans, Mongolians and other peoples scattered along the Silk Road, ethnic groups now buried in the sand of history, like the Sogdians. The caves were also completely forgotten by the Chinese for almost nine centuries. It took Western scholars and explorers at the turn of the twentieth century to bring the caves to the attention of the world before the Chinese begin to take an interest in the caves.

Inside the Caves

Inside the Caves

This Big Buddhist Sculpture is from the Tang Dynasty, built during the reign of Wu Zetian, China's only female emperor. Though its hard to see from our surreptiously taken photo, this Buddha is wearing feminine clothing and is more endowed in the chest than most men. Scholars suggest that this may secretly be an image of Emperor Wu Zetian pretending to be a Buddhist image.

This Big Buddhist Sculpture is from the Tang Dynasty, built during the reign of Wu Zetian, China’s only female emperor. Though its hard to see from our surreptiously taken photo, this Buddha is wearing feminine clothing and is more endowed in the chest than most men. Scholars suggest that this may secretly be an image of Emperor Wu Zetian pretending to be a Buddhist image.

The Mogao Caves are amazing. A wealth of manuscripts was taken by explorers back to the West. These manuscripts prove the amount of trade in ideas and people that were occurring along the Silk Road. The caves contained copies of the Jesus Sutras, a collection of Christian texts in Classical Chinese. They also discovered a copy of the Bible written in Syriac, a language important in Eastern Christianity that once penetrated this far east.

Christian Cross found in Dunhuang

Christian Cross found in Dunhuang

Dunhuang is what the Silk Road was all about, the exchange of people and ideas. Today, it is largely inundated with tourists, but, even for me, it is hard to be cynical when staring at a copy of Psalms written in Syriac.

A Copy of Psalms written in Syriac and found in the Dunhuang Caves

A Copy of Psalms written in Syriac and found in the Dunhuang Caves

Lily’s Neighbors – Part IV

Drink_Horse_One_Army_in_China

Make sure to read the previous posts: here is the first, the second and the third post. These three posts will give the background necessary to understand this sad post, the final in the series of post at Lily’s house in Drink Horse One Army.

On our first evening in the village, Lily’s father took us around to introduce us to the neighbors and help us get our bearings. A small clutch of villagers circled around us as Galen began to film them. Of the group, one woman in her forties, her hair drawn back in a short pony-tail, seemed most interested in us as foreigners. She was Lily’s family’s next-door neighbor. They shared a wall with us.

Lee, the neighbor and Lily's Father

Lee, the neighbor and Lily’s Father

One of the first things she asked us was, “Do you have government-enforced family planning in your country?” Behind us, on one of the village’s walls, was a propaganda sign reminding people about the government mandated one-child policy, suggesting it would make them happy.

Family Planning

Family Planning

“No,” I responded, “we don’t have any family planning from the government. You can have as many children as you want.” As an example, I mentioned some of my Mormon friends and their litters of children.

Nearby, her only daughter stood silently watching us. The girl had a quarter size scab beneath her left eye. She was wearing a school uniform, a blue and white wind suit. The scab looked as though it had been healing for almost a week.

You can just barely see the daughter's bruise here.

You can just barely see the daughter’s bruise here.

The mother was unhappy with her lot in life, but it was not immediately clear why. Many women in the countryside have tough lives. Rural China is a hard place to be a woman.

She complained about how expensive school was. When she was growing up, school only cost a few dollars. Now, they were charging more than a thousand dollars, she said. She asked how it was in the U.S. I told her, everything before college was free.

As we talked, two men came up to us, one of them the husband of the unhappy woman. It was clear from their rabble-rousing that they were drunk. It was almost two hours before sunset, still early. It was one of their birthdays, the men said. They were celebrating.

The husband said little to me. Instead, he stumbled around our little circle, staring at his wife as we talked. Moving closer to her, he popped her on the back of the head. I had trouble telling if it was playful or threatening. She popped him right back. He wheeled around more and grabbed his daughter by the chin, examining the wound beneath her eye before pushing her away.

The drunk husband began to argue with his wife. I had trouble understanding what he said, but I gathered that he did not like her taking an interest in us, and she did not like him constantly wasting their money boozing and gambling.

“Well, why don’t you go find yourself some more foreigners to talk with?” he said.

“”Where would I find them around here? I’d have to go to Dunhuang. That is three hours away.”

Guard Dog

Guard Dog

As things got more heated, Lily’s father urged us away, so as not to inadvertently cause more trouble. We walked around the village more, looking at the mud plastered houses, the stalls enclosing sheep and goats, the guard dogs on short chain metal leashes leaping at us as we passed. The men were drunks, the father explained. Whenever they got money, they would drink and eat and gamble and smoke, but they didn’t get all that much money, since they spent too much time drinking and not enough working. Each month, the government gave them two hundred r.m.b. per person, six hundred for the family, almost one hundred dollars. With this money, the family scraped by.

That night, after dinner, we talked more with Lily’s parents. At around ten, we turned in. The guest bedroom shared a wall with the neighbors’ house. Through the wall separating us, we could hear the high-pitched scream and the dull sound of thuds. I could not tell if the drunk man was beating his wife or his daughter. Screams alternated strangely as they echoed through the wall; he might have been hitting them both. At times, it sounded like the wife was hitting back. We waited, trying to think if we could do anything. There was nothing. For ten or fifteen minutes, the screams continued. Then they suddenly stopped.

Night Sky above Drink Horse One Army Village as the beatings were occurring

Night Sky above Drink Horse One Army Village as the beatings were occurring

Lily’s Family – Part III

Drink_Horse_One_Army_in_China

Make sure to check out Part I and Part II before reading this post.

Lily’s mother was waiting for us in the basketball court as Mr. Gao’s van pulled up. She was well dressed for a middle-aged village woman, wearing tight pants, high heels and pearls. I greeted her warmly, and she welcomed us into her house.

At first, our meeting was awkward. Our conversation was stilted, not unlike when strangers who have little to say are forced to mingle. Lily was not there to formally introduce us.

Cross-Stitch of the Great Wall

Cross-Stitch of the Great Wall

Lily’s mother was a cross-stitcher and had made a six-foot by two-foot cross stitch hanging above the sofa which read, “May our home and the multitude of things rise up and go well.” The craftsmanship was magnificent, and I told her so. “Thank you. It took me all winter to complete,” she responded, smiling. “There is little farmwork in the winter, so I cross-stitch much of the time.” She showed me a pillowcase she was doing for Lily’s wedding, and I told her my grandmother was a crocheter, similar to cross-stitching.

The more we talked, the more Lily’s mom warmed up to us. We talked about them and how they had come to Drink Horse One Army.

Lily's Mother Picking Lunch

Lily’s Mother Picking Lunch

They were not originally from Drink Horse One Army. They had moved to the Drink Horse One Army village from Wuwei, a Silk Road city near Huazangsi, back when Lily was only three, in 1992. Lily’s father was legally blind and the land that their family owned in Wuwei was already too small to be divided any more between him and his three brothers. At some point, they had an uncle living out in this area, and he was able to find a plot for them to farm as a way to help them out.

Lily's Parents, Concrete Workers and Me

Lily’s Parents, Concrete Workers and Me

Lily’s father returned home, caked in the gray dirt of hard work. As with many fathers, he was taciturn. He smiled quietly most of the time, speaking only when necessary. Part of it was his demeanor, but part of it was his inability to, unlike his wife, speak standard Chinese; sometimes I had trouble understanding Lily’s father’s coarse country accent.

When Lily’s family came to Drink Horse One Army, they had spent most of their time farming. They began with a mixture of subsistence farming and some cash crops, but, soon they were able to make a living just from selling their cash crop, sunflower seeds. Summers were bustling. Spring and autumn were busy enough. Winter was dead, but, each year, they had enough put back to get them through.

But Lily’s father was enterprising. Three years ago, they took some money they had made from selling sunflowers and built a cinderblock factory. I should qualify what I mean by factory: the factory was only a hundred yards outside their village, in a small, creekside field. The factory consisted of a cement churn, a mold and a net overhead to keep the desert sun from beating down on them while they worked.

Lily's Mother Watering Bricks

Lily’s Mother Watering Bricks

Each of the bricks sold for three r.m.b., almost half a U.S. dollar. Hired workers used a two-wheel cart to lug the cinderblocks from the cement churn to ground where they could bake in the sun. Lily’s father refilled the cement churn with another worker, while the newly made bricks were lugged back and forth. Lily’s mother, trading her high heels for plastic booties, watered some of the bricks made the day before, to make sure they did not dry out too quickly. While we were there, two men came by on rickety tractors to pull bricks. I helped them load up a hundred something blocks.

Me Loading Cinderblocks

Me Loading Cinderblocks

It was on these bricks that Lily’s family built what, a few years before, would have been considered a small fortune. Their home had a computer, a nice television and a speaker system. The bricks and the hard work they put into them brought in the money for these things.

That night, we talked more at dinner, a simple and delicious dish of noodles and tomatoes. Lily’s father had grown up only eating noodles. Noodles were apparently all most people ate here in Drink Horse One Army and the surrounding province. I asked Lily’s father if he ever ate rice. “No,” he said. “I eat rice, feel full and then, an hour later, I feel hungry. So I just eat noodles.” I laughed and explained to him the American joke about Chinese food.

Worker at Cement Factory

Worker at Cement Factory

They were hoping to expand their factory soon. If they get a bigger factory, they can have the government send workers down from the mountains, places where no one works at all. Then, Lily’s family will start bringing in a lot of money.

Some China watchers claim that the story of China over the last thirty years can be told only in numbers and statistics, the number of people migrating to the cities, the number of factories built, the number of new cities with more than a million people.

Lily's Parents

Lily’s Parents

I reject that sort of thinking. It is stories like Lily’s family that have made China’s transformation so great. It is a story that needs no numbers to tell it. People who were starving in the 1970’s, due to idiotic government policies, are now prospering through hard work.

Of course, not everyone has prospered…

Waiting for a Ride on the New Silk Road

Waiting for a Ride on the New Silk Road

A breakfast of doughnuts made from noodles

A breakfast of doughnuts made from noodles

Cutest Animals along the Silk Road – Part I

As many of you know, I am married to a veterinarian. As I travel along the Silk Road, I have tried to send my wife photos of some of the animals we encounter. Since Sunday is our slowest day as far as clicks go, I’ve decided to throw up some photos just for fun. So, here are some of the cutest animals we have seen along the Silk Road:

Ferocity is thy name

Ferocity is thy name

May I interest you in a bottle of water?

May I interest you in a bottle of water?

I'm not moving

I’m not moving

Baby Yaks!

Baby Yaks!

Out for a Ride

Out for a Ride

Playful Kitten

Playful Kitten

Store Dog

Store Dog

I don't like either of you.

I don’t like either of you.

Village Dogs

Village Dogs

Also, those familiar with my previous blog may remember the Highly Fashionable Dogs of Taiwan:

http://verystinkytofu.com/2014/05/29/highly-fashionable-dogs-of-taiwan-12-finale/

Bubonic Plague and the Silk Road

I am happy to announce that Galen and I are far away from Yumen, the city near Drink Horse One Army, featured in this post and this post and to be featured in two more posts. We are happy about this because, if we were there, we might not be making our flights back to the United States.

Why?

Because, a few weeks after we left Yumen, someone there died of Bubonic Plague, and so, the Chinese government has sealed off the city.

Bubonic plague death in Yumen, China sparks quarantine: Xinhua

As the article notes, this has a strange relationship with our project because the Bubonic Plague was likely spread via the Silk Road to Europe, where it may have killed a third of people living on the continent.

Here are some photos we took as we passed through the city:

If you are seeing this right now, you can't leave here, because you are in Yumen.

If you are seeing this right now, you can’t leave here, because you are in Yumen.

Someone we meet in Yumen

Someone we met in Yumen

Village Settings – Part II

Drink_Horse_One_Army_in_China

Make sure to check out Part I of this story.

We arrived in Yumen, Jade Gate, a tiny Silk Road town that, like so many places in China, had no vestiges of its history remaining. I called the number Lily had given us, and, a few minutes later, Mr. Gao appeared with his van. We waited for a few more people while the seventy year-old-man in the front, his white beard grown down to his chest, wandered out of the van to look for something.

Animals in Drink Horse One  Army

Animals in Drink Horse One Army

Leaving Yumen, the dusty little town, all concrete and glass, quickly gave way to green fields and mud caked houses. We were moving into rural China.

Farmer outside Drink Horse One Army

Farmer outside Drink Horse One Army

The village where Lily’s parent’s lived was called Drink Horse One Army. It had been settled in 1964, and was part of a vast expansion westward of the Han Chinese. In Chinese history, there has long been a tradition of armies being sent off to far away places to not only fight but to find a way to survive. Logistics were difficult, so these armies were essentially colonies with guns and ranks, and Drink Horse One Army was a part of this movement. Fields were tilled from desert lands and irrigation channels crisscrossed the hot earth. Trees were planted in villages and along roads to provide shade.

Bird flying through railing near Drink Horse One Army

Bird flying through railing near Drink Horse One Army

In the 1960’s, they grew what they needed to survive, but now, the region is well beyond subsistence farming. Mostly, there are vast fields of sunflowers, their brown and golden faces shining back at the beaming sun. Corn and grapes are also grown, but sunflower seeds are the most important component of the village’s economy.

Fields

Fields

The village itself was a collection of a hundred or so mud houses built in the 90’s. The mud walls hid a variety of houses behind them, some of them nice, some of them falling apart, depending on the wealth of the family that lived within the walls.

In the center of the village was a shoddy basketball court and a small water tower. Dogs roamed the streets, some owned, some not. Old men drank and played mahjong in the shade along the walls of buildings, women chatting in the alleyways between the rows of the mud houses.

Up to No Good

Up to No Good

In some ways, this was off-track from our project. Though rural, it was not at all natural. Lily had told me that there were some places nearby where we could have gone to camp, but there really were none. As far as we could see, there were only vast fields of sunflowers and corn and rows of trees shading the road. There was no place here that the hand of man had left untouched.

Fields

Fields

Yet, in another way, we were not that far off-track. Our project was about looking at the Silk Road, and Drink Horse One Army was only a five minute walk from G312, the highway linking Gansu to the west of China, the contemporary descendant of the old Silk Road. Semis plying this route brought cheaply made Chinese products into the Stans of Central Asia and brought back raw materials from the Stans to China to make those goods. Drink Horse One Army waited in the shadows of this new Silk Road, sometimes watching changes pass it by and some times changing with it.

Part of a wind turbine moving along the New Silk Road

Part of a wind turbine moving along the New Silk Road

Looking down the New Silk Road

Looking down the New Silk Road

Mr. Gao, the man driving the van, pulled across the basketball court where a smiling forty-five-year-old woman was waiting for us.

Water Tower in the Village

Water Tower in the Village