Bezeklik Caves

Turpan_and_Bezeklik_and_SanbaoxiangBezeklik_Area

The sun was beating down on us. We walked the half mile down the road to where the Bezeklik Caves compound was.

The River Valley beneath the Bezeklik Caves' cliffface

The River Valley beneath the Bezeklik Caves’ cliffface

Caves is not an accurate way of describing Bezeklik. Bezeklik is actually a series of man-made grottos carved into the side of a tall cliffface above a small river. The Mutou river runs from Shengjin in the north, a green split of dense vineyards on the north side of the Flaming Mountains. From Shengjin, the river carves a canyon through those mountains, before pouring out into the Turpan Basin, the lowest elevation in China.

20140720_133347

In Chinese, Bezeklik is called the Thousand Buddha Caves. There are only seventy-seven caves remaining, and many of these have been badly damaged. In the past hundred and fifty years, explorers from the West and Japan snatched some of the paintings up, chiseling the artwork straight off the grotto walls. Others were destroyed by Uighurs after they converted to Islam or Maoists when they were in an anti-religious fervor.

You are no longer able to view this piece of art in China, though it may be on display at Harvard

You are no longer able to view this piece of art in China, though it may be on display at Harvard

Still, the artwork that is still left in these caves is fantastic. From what I have been able to find, most of the paintings are from the ninth to thirteenth century. This was the period when the area was ruled over by Uighurs from the nearby Silk Road Oasis of Gaochang in the Kara-Khoja empire.  During this period, Uighurs were largely Buddhist, though other religions competed with Buddhism, though Manicheism and Nestorian Christianity also made strong showings among the Uighurs and the rest of the people living in Gaochang.

20140720_132338

It was in this context that these caves were painted with beautiful Buddhist artworks. The financing was provided by rich nobles and merchants, grown fat off Silk Road trade, and, like the Indulgences that Martin Luther railed against, this functioned as a sort of spiritual accounting system. If you financed Buddhist artwork, it would buy you good karma and a better place in the next life.

20140720_133340

And the artwork that remained was still vivid and a clear reminder of the trade in goods and ideas that once flowed past what is now a backwater. The people depicted in the artwork showed a variety of peoples passing through the area, though, more of the interesting ethnic paintings had been taken to museums far away.

20140720_134853

Many of the grottos' interiors look like this

Many of the grottos’ interiors look like this

One interesting thing is that, for some reason, no photos are allowed. We had seen signs, though the signs did not make it clear if it was photography or just flash photography that was not allowed. We assumed it was the latter, since the light from a flash can sometimes damage paintings like this, but we found out we were wrong when a security guard yelled at Galen when he had his camera out, shouting, “Noh, noh, noh,” the extent of his English vocabulary.

20140720_133340

For the rest of our visit, that guard followed Galen around. However, the other security guards thought it was too hot to care, so I was allowed to wander unaccompanied.

20140720_132949

While Galen distracted the one guard who cared, I took these photos surreptitiously with my phone.

20140720_132257

As we were leaving, I asked the director of the Bezeklik caves, an middle-aged codger, why photos were not allowed. He told me, as I suspected, that the flashes of cameras can damage the walls. I asked why flashless photography was not allowed. The codger got ruffled, struggling for an answer. In the end, all he said were that absolutely no photos were allowed, and there was nothing to change that.

20140720_132347 20140720_132621 20140720_131923 20140720_131823 20140720_131504

Hitchhiking to Bezeklik

Turpan_and_Bezeklik_and_SanbaoxiangBezeklik_Area

The Flaming Mountains and the New Silk Road

The Flaming Mountains and the New Silk Road

I was satisfied with biking out to the Ruins of Jiaohe and the Emin Minaret, but we really wanted to get back to hitchhiking.

The Flaming Mountains

The Flaming Mountains

We took a bus out to the rural town near the Bezeklik Caves, Erbaoxiang, or Second Fortress Village. After a forty minute, twenty plus mile ride across the desert, past the south face of the Flaming Mountains, we were dropped off at an intersection in a rural village and pointed in the direction of the caves. Motorcycle repair

Some villagers were doing repairs on motorbikes in a sort of dusty, streetside mechanic shop. I asked them if they knew anyone going towards the Bezeklik Caves, but all they wanted to do was arrange an overpriced cab for us. After arguing for a while, we left them, walking off in the direction of the caves, trying to flag down a ride. Hitchhiking in a Three Wheeled Cart

Within a few minutes, a farmer on a small, three-wheeled cart pulled over. Someone was sitting on the lip of the cart’s bed. I spoke to the driver, but he could not speak Chinese. Galen and I exhausted the three words we knew in Uighur, and, through some wild gesticulations, were able to communicate to him that we wanted a ride in the direction that he was going, towards Bezeklik. He nodded, and we hopped into the bed.

Hitchhiking in a Three Wheeled Cart

We zoomed down this country road for a mile or two, the breeze shaving the edge off the heat. At another intersection, he stopped, pointing us towards Bezeklik. We hopped out of the bed, saying, “Rakhmat,” or thank you in Uighur, and he disappeared down a small dirt lane. Alleys Along the Way

The desert sun was approaching noon, local time. We waited around for a few minutes, buying bottles of water and trying to flag down more vehicles. A handful of Uighur men were gathered in the shade, looking down at something. I squinted to see what they were all hunched over. 20140720_122108

I was startled. It was something I had never seen in China: a chess board. The Chinese have their own version of chess, but they have a completely different board; pieces occupy the intersections of lines rather than checkered squares and the board is bifurcated by a river. Immediately, I realized that the Uighur men were not playing Chinese chess, they were using the chessboard familiar to me. Soon, we were able to flag down a Uighur kid in a new sedan. In his Car

“We’re going towards the Bezeklik Caves. Are you going that direction?” I asked him. “Sure. How much are you willing to pay?” He replied. “Oh, we’re hitchhiking. We are looking for rides that don’t cost money.” He thought for a moment. “Okay,” he said, waving us in. 744A6773

Galen as Monkey at the tourist trap where we got dropped off

Over the fifteen minute ride, weaving through a canyon that cut through the Flaming Mountains, our conversation wound through the channels familiar to any foreigner who has had a conversation in China, where we were from, where we were going, how long did our flight take. The kid was young, probably not yet twenty. He wore the white cap that more devout Muslims wear. The sedan clearly was not his, but a parent’s or older family member’s. He drove carefully, as though he was not used to it. As we chatted, it was clear that he was interested in us. I wondered if he had seen us looking for rides and taken his family’s new car just so that he could meet us.

Lee as Pig at the tourist trap where we got dropped off

We came upon the parking lot of a tourist attraction. It looked a little kitschy to be ancient Buddhist cave artwork, but we got out anyways, saying “Rakhmat” and waving goodbye. The kid turned back around, going back the way he had come. We went to the ticket stand, but, it turned out, we had been dropped off at the wrong place. This was another tacky tourist attraction, something having to do with the Journey to the West and Uighurs, a vague amalgamation of a lot of the stereotypes that people from the Interior China thought about Xinjiang. The caves, the ticket man told us, were a half a mile further down the road.

The sun baking down on us, we ambled on. Two things occupied my thoughts as we walked. First, it seemed clear that the kid who had given us the ride had just been doing it to meet us. He had not been going this direction. He just wanted to talk to us. Second and stranger was that, though he grew up only a few miles from the Bezeklik Caves, he was not familiar enough with them to know where they actually were. He had probably never visited the Caves himself. Why was there such a disconnect? He was Muslim and the caves were Buddhist, but it was possible that some of his ancestors had lived in the area when the caves were painted, that other ancestors had come from faraway lands, traveling in the same caravans that carried Buddhist missionaries and artisans. Why was his connection to this art a stone’s throw from his home so tenuous?

In Celebration of Genocide

Emin_Minaret_in_Turpan

All of the guidebooks mentioned Emin Minaret. The tower was built in 1777 and finished in 1778. Its construction was blessed by the Qing Dynasty’s Qianlong Emperor to honor Emin Khoja, a local ruler and general who had teamed up with the Qianlong Emperor, though the details of their collaboration were always left vague. I scratched around for more information, in both Chinese or in English, but I found little.

Handsome Gentleman Biking to Emin Minaret

Handsome Gentleman Biking to Emin Minaret

Still, as one of the few structures remaining from the Muslim Uighur Khanates that ruled Turpan and much of the Silk Road surrounding the Taklimakan Desert for much of the last five centuries, I wanted to get a look at the Emin Minaret, a tower more than one hundred and forty feet tall looming over acres of vineyards just outside of the city of Turpan.

20140718_175210

We biked out to the Minaret. From a quarter mile away, we could see the tower. Instead of continuing to follow the signs directing us to the entrance, we wove our rinky-dink bikes through village dirt roads. Just two hundred feet from the Emin Minaret complex, we ditched our bikes in grape fields and made our way closer on foot.

The mosque was majestic, something straight out of Central Asia or the Middle East. The minaret tower itself was made out of earthen brown bricks and slowly narrowed as it moved from its base to its rounded cap, lines circling it horizontally. It looked like an ice cream cone turned upside down.

20140718_175301

Beside it, there was a mosque with a large brick arched gate and a squatty, square building that looked unassuming but had twenty-five thousand square feet of worship space.

Still, I wanted to know more about why the Emin Minaret was important. We left the tower and continued our travels, but I dug deeper.

Previously on the blog, I mentioned that Xinjiang is really two separate places, divided by the Tianshan Mountains. South Xinjiang, where Turpan and the Emin Minaret are, is largely desert and has a largely Uighur population.

North Xinjiang is different. North Xinjiang looks like Mongolia, with wide open Steppe and smaller, cooler deserts. The population in North Xinjiang is a mixture of Han Chinese with a scattering of other ethnic groups, but this was not always the case. The Dzungar Mongolians, a confederation of tribes related to the Mongols of Genghis Khan, used to lord over North Xinjiang. In the 1620’s, the Dzungar Mongolians formed an empire and began a campaign of conquest. They conquered the Silk Road Uighur Oasises to the south of their empire, like Turpan, and rampaged through modern day Tibet, Kyrgyzstan, Kazakhstan and Russia. They even began to challenge the relatively young dynasty in Beijing, the Qing Dynasty.

The Qing decided to destroy this threat. After several campaigns to check the Dzungarian’s power, Emperor Qianlong ordered that the Dzungar Empire be destroyed and that all Dzungarians be eliminated. Around half a million Dzungarian Mongolians were slaughtered. Dzungarian men were shown no mercy. Women and children were divided between Qing soldiers as part of the spoils of war, as slaves or sex slaves. An expert on genocide called it “arguably the eighteenth century genocide par excellence.”

 

A monument built to celebrate a genocide

A monument built to celebrate a genocide

The Uighur Khanates in South Xinjiang had long resented the rule of their Mongolian neighbors to the north. The collaboration I mentioned earlier between the Qianlong Emperor and the Emin Khoja, the ruler of Turpan who the Emin Minaret was built in honor of, was him providing assistance that made the genocide of the Dzungarian Mongolians possible. The Emin Minaret was built as a way to celebrate the Emin Khoja’s role in the genocide.

20140718_175439

I want to push back against the narrative of the poor Uighur, a narrative common in Western treatment of the topic. Uighurs are not victims of history. They have actively taken part in the bloody history of the Silk Road. Though they are persecuted now, they have persecuted others in the past. Though they are now in conflict with the Han Chinese, they once worked with the Han to eliminate a greater threat.

Grapes Given

The road from the Jiaohe ruins

The road from the Jiaohe ruins

The afternoon was hot. It was easily over a hundred degrees. We were in the dry, Turpan depression, near the second lowest point on Earth. My idea to bike to and back from the Jiaohe Ruins had seemed like a better idea earlier in the morning. Now, after two and a half hours wandering around the Jiaohe ruins without water, the desert was getting to us.

Bicycling alongside the never-ending grape fields, I asked several people where we could buy raisins, as a snack to tide us over until we got something to eat in town, but no one was able to say. In a sea of grapes, no one seemed to know where I could buy raisins.

The house

The house

We passed a brick house surrounded on three sides by acres of grape vines. A sign hung on the front wall of the house, advertising that they served meals there. It was four o’clock Beijing time, two o’clock local time, but I figured they might have raisois to sell us.

I knocked on a red wooden gate which marked the entrance to the house. At first, there was no response, but soon, I heard the soft scratching of a girl’s footsteps.

She opened the door slightly, her brown face peaking out at us under her black and yellow hijab.

“Sorry to bother you, but we were wondering if you sold any raisins here,” I asked.

She did not say anything, waving us in. We stood in the atrium, and she disappeared into a side room.

I had seen diagrams of Uighur houses, but I had never gotten the chance to go into one. Behind the gate, there was a large atrium. The atrium functioned as a garage, as an area for welcoming guests and, in the summer, as a place to sleep, when the interior rooms of the house were too hot in the 110+ heat. Pressed against the wall, there was a sewing machine and a small three-wheeled cart used by farmers in China. Opposite, was a motorcycle. In the back, were several fancy looking tables, where they served guests who stopped by for lunch.

The Atrium

The Atrium

Like many Uighur atriums, the thing above us was not so much a roof as it was wooden poles covered in grape vines. With only half an inch of rain each year, a fully covered roof was not needed. The lush green leaves of the grape vine provided shade to keep the atrium cool while still letting in enough natural light to see.

The girl with the black and yellow hijab returned from the side room. She had no raisins, but she signaled that we should wait for a few minutes. Then, she returned to her work at the sewing machine. I realized she probably did not speak Chinese. The sewing machine hummed on and off as the girl pushed material beneath the needle. I wondered how much of what I had said she was able to understand.

We waited a few more minutes, but no one came out to sell us raisins.

“Umm… I guess we’ll just head out. Thank you very much though.” I said, unsure of what to say.

The girl stood up and grabbed a pair of vine clippers, moving slowly past us, again not saying anything. She took a small ladder and snipped off a bunch of grapes larger than my balding head, handing them to us.

“Oh, thank you.” I said, pulling out my wallet. “How much should I pay you?”

She waved away my wallet. This was a gift, she signaled.

“Oh, wow. Thank you a lot.” We had done nothing to deserve this gift. As a part of Muslim and Central Asian culture, guests are treated with a hospitality rarely seen in China or America.

We led ourselves to the wooden gate and out of the atrium where our bikes were parked. The girl in the black and yellow hijab closed the door behind us.

The Ruins of Jiaohe

Turpan in China

Turpan in China

Jiaohe_in_relation_to_Turpan

We were able to get rinky-dink bikes and make our way out of Kashgar. It was not hitchhiking, but it was an unconventional means of transportation, and it gave us a chance to meet people and get a feel for the countryside along the six mile stretch between the city and the ruins of Jiaohe.

Biking out to Jiaohe

Biking out to Jiaohe

We pedaled out of Turpan, taller buildings giving way to single-story mud brick farmhouses. Soon, even these buildings appeared infrequently. The landscape shifted into grape farms, long strings of green among the red dirt fields with a handful of houses with large, Uighur-style gates fronting the road.

Crossing a small bridge, we chained our bikes up in the parking lot and entered the ruins of Jiaohe, an ancient Silk Road capital.

Galen at Turpan

Galen at Turpan

Satellite Photos of Jiaohe -  Surrounded by two rivers, Jiaohe is a small, leaf-shaped stone plateau

Satellite Photos of Jiaohe – Surrounded by two rivers, Jiaohe is a small, leaf-shaped stone plateau

Unlike many other ancient Silk Road cities, significant amounts of Jiaohe’s original architecture still remain, in part because the city was not so much built as it was carved. In Chinese, Jiaohe means “river intersection.” It was so named because of two small desert rivers come together at the city’s southeastern foot. Between these two rivers, the city is built out of a leaf-shaped plateau with tall cliff faces on either side, providing a natural defense and leaving much of the city standing, unlike the nearby Gaochang, which I would visit a few days later.

Entering Jiaohe

Entering Jiaohe

Is this a Silk Road ruin, or just a cave?

Is this a Silk Road ruin, or just a cave?

At first, the hulking remains of buildings seemed like they could almost be naturally formed from the rock, with large caves dug out of mud structures, patches of grass growing in places that were once plazas, the corners of structures that were once walls standing like crenelated hoodoos in the open.

Windows

Windows

The walls, though, were regularly pockmarked with holes and the towers were far too square to be naturally formed. Windows were clearly carved into rocks. The deeper in we walked, the more man-made the ruins came to look.

Few ruins in China remain as well preserved as this; see our visit to the fakish Great Wall, built in the last decade. In China, everything must be torn down and rebuilt. Nothing is allowed to remain untouched.

Mommy, watch me destroy history!

Mommy, watch me destroy history!

Near the entrance of Jiaohe, we saw one of the reasons why. A mother in a high-slit dress and pumps, protecting herself from the sun with an umbrella and sunglasses, took a photo of her son jumping on some of the mud ruins. After a few minutes, a pair of guards yelled at her and her son jumped off the ruins. However, when we later came past, the guards, employed to protect the ruins, were taking a break, lazing in the shade on one of the ruins.

Paid to protect, guards on their break they climb on the ruins themself

Paid to protect, guards on their break climb on the ruins themselves

There is little signage to explain anything, but Jiaohe has a long history. A city had been there since before Julius Caesar, though I was unclear on how much of what we were seeing remained from that time. The city functioned as a capital of several Silk Road kingdoms and a major node of commerce and government for those traveling to or from China. The city had a variety of rulers, from Han Chinese, to Uighurs, to Kyrgyzs, but it eventually was destroyed in the thirteenth century by Genghis Khan as he swept across Eurasia.

Jiaohe is built out of mud and bricks

Jiaohe is built out of mud and bricks

Near the entrance, there were a sizable number of visitors roaming the park. I even watched a tour bus with a flag-touting tour guide coming into the ruins with us. After five minutes, however, I realized we were alone. “Okay, everybody, let’s go.” I remembered the tour guide telling his charges. “We only have thirty minutes until we need to be back on the bus.”

Other places had been packed with tourists, yet they had not been as grand as Jiaohe. On the way to Jiaohe, we had passed an “Ancient Uighur Village,” a disneyish reconstruction of a Uighur village full of tour buses. Strangely, here, amongst the spires of real history, in a city where Genghis Khan had raped and pillaged, few tourists could be bothered to spend much time here.

Hoodoos

Hoodoos

We wandered deeper into Jiaohe for two and a half hours. The innards of the ruins were crossed by roads dug out of the stone walls. Deep in the northwest corner of the ruins, we came across an ancient Buddhist temple, surrounded by a score of pagodas, though only the pagodas’ bases remained.

Once a monument to Buddhism and a symbol of the stretch of ideas throughout the Silk Road

Once a monument to Buddhism and a symbol of the stretch of ideas throughout the Silk Road

This forest of pagodas had once been an important monument to a religion that has long since disappeared from these parts, as part of a funnel pumping Buddhism into China. Now, the people here who were once Buddhist are Muslim and all that remains of their fathers’ faith is this monument.

744A6465 744A6457 744A6506 744A6433 744A6415 744A6432 744A6452

Mummies of Turpan

Turpan_in_China

I entered the museum’s exhibit hall. The air was quiet and the entrance dark. The sensation was not normal for China. It felt like I was entering a church, somewhere holy and slightly frightening.

744A6874

Inside the first exhibit, the rumpled body of a man lay on a wooden bed, his legs folded up, a white towel laying across his waist. Initially, I thought a mask was covering the upper half of his face and head, though, the more I looked, the less certain of that I was. I could not see them, but, I read that his eyes were blue. His hair, a rusty brown, completely different from the jet black hair of the Han Chinese. A hoop, possibly an earring, lies pressed against his chin, right where his ear would have been. I could count his sunken ribs until they disappeared under the white towel.

744A6875

The mummy was a two thousand seven hundred years old shaman. Beside him, they had found a basket full of almost two pounds of marijuana, which archaeologists assume was either for religious or psychoactive purposes, the oldest known use of marijuana as a drug. In other words, this man was the world’s oldest known drug dealer.

744A6876

In the glass case beside the mummy, three skulls and a foot glowed in the yellow light. Two of the skulls had several holes on top and the foot was wrapped in some sort of sock. Though they were fused together, I could still distinguish the individual toes and the small indentions of toenails. I found the level of detail preserved equally fascinating and disturbing. So much was still left.

744A6877

Being on the northern edge of the Taklimakan Desert, Turpan is hot. It is the hottest place in China. The average high for July is 104 Fahrenheit, though it has been measured as high as 119.  Rain is a rare event. In a year, Turpan gets little more than half an inch of rain. Hot and dry, these are perfect conditions for preservation of the human body through mummification.

Although Egypt is most famous for mummies, other places, like Turpan, also have rich histories of mummification, and the Turpan Museum is the beneficiary of this. Mummies have been excavated throughout Xinjiang, some of them red-headed mummies from ethnic groups related to Europeans. The mummies in Turpan Museum were only discovered in nearby mountains in 2007, and are the star attraction of the museum.

744A6895

Despite these amazing mummies, the museum was strangely quiet as I wound my way around the mummy exhibit. In the half hour I spent there, less than ten visitors came in. I talked to one of the museum docents. Normally, she said, between May and September, the museum would be filled with an average of three to five thousand visitors a day. But this year, because of the outbreaks of ethnic violence in Xinjiang, they had not had more than a thousand visitors a day. On the day I visited, I guessed there were probably no more than five hundred visitors.

744A6884

Though I was disappointed that more people were not getting to see these amazing mummies, this drop in visitation did give the mummy exhibit a quiet, holy feeling.

744A6888

I approached another mummy, a child, resting on what appeared to be a wooden raft. His internal organs had disappeared but remains of skin were wrapped around his rib cage in splotches of brown, orange and white. I moved closer to his head. His hair was a light brown and his eyes almost looked blue. His lips were pursed around his upper teeth, and it looked as though he were grinning at me. He stared back at me across the centuries.